I know what you are saying
to yourself: Great, another hot take onBlack Panther, the zillionth one so far. Hear me out,
though. I am not really into comic
books. I can think of only one comic book series, recently, which I have
watched in full, Jessica Jones. That should tell you something. I have gone to
comic book movies, because my children have dragged me to them, but these
experiences have only reinforced my understanding that I am not the audience
for these flicks. So, I really didn’t know what to expect when my 17-year-old
wanted me to go to Black Panther with him, but go I did.
Wow. Like many people, I was blown away, and you can
read critics’ reviews, to find out
why. You don’t need me for that. I did want to address the message, which I
found uplifting, even if my kid is right that the way it was presented was a
little too ham-fisted. I really could not stop thinking about the film and its
message, and I wondered why. Then I got it. I could not stop thinking about it,
because it is so close to the work we do here every day.
Earlier this week on this
blog, and last week on social media and via email, we shared the news of the Center
for Social Innovation’s first public reporton incredible
work they have engaged in with the Metro Dallas Homeless Alliance (MDHA),
and five other cities, towards establishing racial equity in homeless services,
throughSPARC(Supporting
Partnerships for Anti-Racist Communities), a new research and action program. One of the ideas that we, at
MDHA, have brought to the forefront of Dallas
consciousness these last 16 months, is that homelessness in Dallas is largely about race. When around
60-70% of those experiencing homelessness are African-American, the question
Larry James, CEO of CitySquare was asked in public in mid-2016, “Why do you
have to make this about race,” is self-evident in its willful blindness. Once you remove the scales
from your eyes, be it regarding homelessness in Dallas, be it regarding the history of
colonialism, you have two options that can explain the challenges Africans and
African-Americans face. Option 1, and this is the option our region of the
country held on to firmly into the mid-sixties: There is something wrong with
Africans and African-Americans. Hopefully, that sentence just made you flinch,
but don’t think that approach does not still exist in our world. The “great”
thing about this approach is that it demands no action on our part, as a local
or global society. Option 2, and, spoiler
alert, this option is the one backed up by a pesky thing called data or facts:
What we see today is the result of how colonial powers treated Africa, and our
society in Dallas
treated and often still treats African Americans.
Black Panther allows us to
imagine what would have happened had colonial powers not plundered Africa of its natural and human resources. Beyond that,
it imagines an Africa with superior natural
resources, that breeds technology beyond our wildest dreams. Though my
17-year-old might think this is a little too inelegant a presentation, I find
the simplicity of it refreshing. The message of the Afro-Futuristic past and
present of Wakanda is: The only difference between the condition of real world Africa and its diaspora and Wakanda is that the former
lacks the resources of the latter, and that the latter suffered the trauma that
did not befall the former. To bring it back to homelessness in Dallas: The
difference between the white person who is housed and the black person
experiencing homelessness, is that the black person comes from a traumatized
community, robbed of its resources, and the white person does not.
Ok, so practically speaking,
what now? The movie explores three paths. Path 1 is the status quo, the path of
Wakanda up until that point, which was, essentially, to do nothing. Both Killmongerand the Black Panther realize that that path is no
longer tenable. Path 2 is the path of Killmonger, the villain, who is
uncharacteristically for comic books, rather nuanced. He favors the Wakandans
treating the world like the world treated Africa.
Path 3 is the path that the Black Panther chooses, that Wakanda begin to share
its resources with the African Diasporas, in order to create racial
equity.
We, as Americans,
confronting a crisis of homelessness, that has lasted for forty years have to
decide what to do in our real world. TheSPARC reportis unflinching in
its assessment: The homelessness field
stands at a crossroads: continue to use color-blind strategies to solve an
entrenched social problem that disproportionately impacts people of color, or
embrace a racial equity approach to addressing homelessness… Commitment to
racial equity must permeate all other tactics and strategies that cities,
counties, states, and the nation use to prevent and end homelessness… Unless we
as a field address structural racism within housing, homelessness response,
criminal justice, child welfare, employment, education, and health care, we
will continue to witness high rates of homelessness for people of color. Our
responses must be ambitious and focused on dismantling racist structures,
systems, and programs. We, in Dallas, stand at a crossroads too. There is
no escaping that. Will we have the courage to rise to the challenge? Will we
have the courage to marshal our abundant resources to end homelessness and
create racial equity in this and all other areas? Only time will tell.
The book synopsis was led by Randy Mayeux, renowned
scholar and longtime book reviewer at CitySquare's Urban Engagement Book Club.
Our good friends, Larry James and Rev. Dr. Michael Waters, joined Randy for the
Q&A part of this exciting event, and expounded on how the lessons of Toxic
Inequality can be applied to race, poverty and homelessness in Dallas.
It’s hard to believe that
the first time we discussed the disproportionate representation of African
Americans in Dallas’ homeless population, on this blog, was just a little
over nine months ago. Since then, we have endeavored to make the glaring racial
disparities in homelessness an integral part of every conversation surrounding
homelessness in our community.
With the help of a generous
grant fromUnited Way of Metropolitan Dallas’ Unite Dallas Relief Fund, we are
in the midst of a research and action program from the Center
for Social Innovation(C4) titled “Racism and Homelessness - Addressing
Inequity in 10 American Cities”, nicknamed SPARC (Supporting
Partnerships for Anti-Racist Communities). In the words of C4, “While no single
initiative can end structural racism across all systems, we believe,” that
through this initiative we can, “create positive change in attitudes and
behaviors that will begin to close the racial gap that has led to the
disproportionate prevalence… of homelessness among African Americans.”
Hard Conversations: Racism
and Homelessness
We launched the program,
with a number of activities in late November 2016, including a
first round of training for service providers, and the first meeting of a
planning body to help MDHA and C4 shepherd this program in Dallas. The highlight that month was an
installment of our Hard Conversations series onRacism
and Homelessness. It was a packed house, in what could only be
described as a combination of a church service and rock concert, with some
serious learning and consciousness raising.
In February, C4 staff spent
a week here in Dallas
collecting qualitative data. They held focus groups with individuals
experiencing homelessness, case managers and other front-line professionals,
and mid to upper management personnel of service providers. They recorded about
twenty Story corps style interviews with persons experiencing homelessness,
where these individuals shared their life histories. Through this qualitative
research, which they are conducting in all participating cities, they are looking
for patterns in how people of color enter homelessness and what barriers
prevent them from rapidly and permanently exiting homelessness.
We also spent time that
week, MDHA and C4 staff together, meeting with a variety of stakeholders in the
community to seek their guidance and input, including a large group of
African-American and allied clergy, and leaders of other anti-racism efforts in
our community. We also had another in-person meeting of the local planning body
we had formed to help us shepherd this effort, whom we have and continue to
meet with regularly over the phone.
2017 State of the Homeless
Address
During the State of the Homeless Address in March,
Cindy J. Crain, MDHA’s President and CEO, shared the relevant data on racism
and homelessness, from the 2017 Homeless Count, and the Homeless Management
Information System (HMIS). These numbers reiterated what the 2016 Homeless
Count numbers showed us already: 60-70% of those experiencing homelessness in
our community are African-American. She vowed that MDHA would continue to work
to, “counter the systemic influences that created such extraordinary disparity
with systemic changes.”
Currently, as C4 analyzes
the qualitative data collected here in Dallas at the end of February, they are
also in the process of collecting quantative data from the HMIS system, which
they will subject to rigorous analysis. They have also begun to connect us with
the other cities they are working with in a budding online learning
collaborative, where we are sharing our challenges, and how we are beginning to
tackle them. It is fascinating to see the commonalities and differences between
the different communities regarding the connections between racism and
homelessness.
C4 encouraged us, from the
beginning of this process, to develop and incorporate structural changes that
could begin to move the needle on racism and homelessness in Dallas. To that end, as we developed our newContinuum of Care (CoC) Strategic Work Plan,
with our partners in theCoCGeneral Assembly, we included
as an overarching goal, addressing racial disparities in homelessness and
service delivery. We encourage you, the reader, to review these action items to
see how you can help.
A key action item pertains
to one of our most important innovations in our homeless response system this
year, theMDHA Homeless Response System Community
Dashboard. It provides a quarterly snapshotof the core
system metrics that inform us on achievements in moving individuals to
permanent housing. We will add an addendum to this important tool, which will
capture, along racial and ethnic lines, who is homeless and in need of housing.
Even more importantly, it will inform the community on how well we are
utilizing the housing resources we have, in a way that promotes racial equity
and begins to eliminate racial disparities in service delivery.
Promoting racial equity in
service delivery begins “at home”. What do we mean by that? During the State of
the Homeless Address, Cindy Crain shared a slide that showed the racial and
gender breakdown of the CEOs/Executive Directors of the main thirty-two service
providers in the homeless arena in Dallas.
The numbers are troubling, to put it mildly: 44% white males, 44% white
females, 6% black males, 6% black females. A key action item is to build on
this, and conduct and publish an annual demographic survey of all senior
management and board officers of federally funded homeless response system
agencies. We can and must begin to move to a more diverse make-up of senior staff,
as well as lay and professional leadership, that better reflects the population
we are all here to serve.
Last Hard Conversation with
Randy Mayeux on Housing First
Later this month, we will
host another public event, related to racism and homelessness, as we seek to
keep this issue front and center in our work.MDHA, CitySquare, and the Dallas
Public Librarywill present a book synopsis of Toxic Inequality: How America’s Wealth Gap
Destroys Mobility, Deepens the Racial Divide, and Threatens Our Future.
Randy Mayeux, renowned scholar and longtime book reviewer at
CitySquare’s Urban Engagement Book Club, will lead the discussion. Larry James
and Rev. Dr. Michael Waters, will join him for the Q&A portion. They will
expound on how the lessons of Toxic Inequality can be applied to race, poverty
and homelessness in Dallas.RSVP today,
so you don’t miss this exciting and informative event!
We look forward to
continuing to work with C4, with our partners, and with the community at large
on addressing this important issue. Together, we can fulfill the vision we
started this process with, and “create positive change in attitudes and
behaviors that will begin to close the racial gap that has led to the
disproportionate prevalence… of homelessness among African Americans.”
British actor, Roger
Daltrey, in one of the iconic American Express card commercials from 1985
How often do you find
yourself without identification? The answer is, probably not that often.
Most of us, in the words of the old American Express commercial, don’t leave
home without it. This is why many find it surprising that over 10% of us do not have a
government-issued photo ID. Not surprisingly, those without an ID
tend to be poor, minorities, and/or elderly.
Many of these same people
manage to navigate life without an ID. However, ending a person’s homelessness
can be challenging, if that person does not have some type of government issued
identification, and cannot afford to get one. It seems that to paraphrase the
same commercial, you can’t end your homelessness without it.
About six weeks ago, Daniel
and Karla*, two neighbors who had experienced homelessness in the past, found
themselves in a pickle. They were both living in permanent supportive housing,
funded by a Federal grant. The agency which had received the grant ceased to
operate, but our grantee,CitySquare, was prepared to keep
the residents in housing. Daniel and Karla each had to present a government issued
ID (at least a birth certificate), but neither of them had one. What were they
to do?
About four weeks ago,
Abraham was experiencing homelessness. He was determined to find a job, so he
could become housed. He knew that he would need a government issued photo ID to
get a job, and that to get the photo ID, he needed a birth certificate. He had
obtained a birth certificate with the help of our partner,The Stewpot,
but alas he could not find it. (It is difficult to keep all your documents and
valuables in place, when you don’t have a home!) He would have to wait an
entire year to be eligible for this help again. What was he to do?
Just three weeks ago,
Richard was experiencing homelessness. CitySquare was helping him get
everything in order, so he could apply for a Dallas Housing Authority voucher.
He had a driver’s license, but it had expired. Without renewing his license, he
would not be able to apply for a voucher. What was he to do?
Fortunately, about two years
ago, through surveys of clients and service providers, MDHA had identified a
variety of needs (beyond housing and supportive services), that Dallas’ homeless
population faced, in their struggle to end their homelessness. One of these
needs was critical documents, such as government issued identification. These
needs may not be covered through existing federal, state and local government
grants, that fund programs for the homeless.
Thus, with the help ofUnited
Way of Metropolitan Dallas, the MDHA Flex Fundwas born. The idea was simple. A minor but
impactful need, such as the lack of a birth certificate or photo ID, impedes a
client from (making progress in) ending his or her homelessness. The Flex Fund
pays for it. That’s all there is to it.
That is how we helped
Daniel, Karla, Abraham and Richard. Their case managers submitted a simple one
page form. The form asks for the client’s information, what the client needs (including
cost and vendor), articulation of how this will help the client end his or her
homelessness, and an explanation of why other resources (including the
client’s) cannot provide (for) it.
A classic Shavon Moore
selfie
Shavon Moore, MDHA’s
Continuum of Care Resource Manager, reviewed each request, approved it, and
provided payment directly to the vendor. In fact, as is often the case with
critical documents, in Daniel, Karla and Abraham’s cases, Shavon could quickly
order the documents and pay for them online. Once they arrived, the case
managers picked them up from the MDHA Offices.
Cindy J. Crain,
MDHA President and CEO, introduced Charles, one of many bona fide Dallas
Housing First success stories to the crowd, and shared the numbers on client
success in Housing First programs in Dallas.If you have read this blog
before, you know those numbers already – 96%!Larry
James, CEO of CitySquare spoke about howThe Cottages at Hickory
Crossingand other CitySquare programs utilize the
Housing First philosophy, and both he and Cindy took questions.
Our good friends from Two
Hats Publishing taped the whole thing, so click here to downloadRandy’s handoutandPowerPoint presentation,
and then click here to watch the whole session:
We posted the above video,
handout, and PowerPoint on theKey DocumentsandHard Conversationspages on our website too, along with an audio recording(does not include Cindy and Larry’s parts). Enjoy learning, and spread the
word!
Research has shown that the best
way to end someone's homelessness is to house them. Now, if you were
unfamiliar with the arena of homelessness, you could be forgiven for wondering
why the last sentence even needs to even be written, or why this even needed to
be researched. Isn't this self-evident? You certainly could be forgiven for not
realizing that within the homelessness arena, throughout the 80s and 90s, and
in some quarters still today, such a statement would be seen as ill-informed,
wrong, and irresponsible! Thankfully, as we have pointed out on this blog before, the jury is
in, and so this idea that the homeless, just like you and me,
fare best when they are housed (with adequate supports in place, where needed),
is now the consensus of researchers in the field, the federal government, and
most practitioners. The story of how this transformation came about, beginning
with one small group of practitioners in New York City, to sweeping the nation
and the globe, is vividly told by those very practitioners, in a book that is
both extremely readable and full of all of the relevant research,Housing First: Ending
Homelessness, Transforming Systems, and Changing Lives.
We are, therefore excited to
announce the return of our series of Hard Conversations, with a book synopsis of this work, presented byRandy Mayeux,
renowned scholar and longtime book reviewer at CitySquare's Urban Engagement
Book Club.
As you probably know, the City of Dallas has been
working with MDHA and partner agencies to close down the TentCity encampment under the I-45
Bridge. This is being done primarily in the interest of the health and
safety of the those experiencing homelessness, as our board member, CEO of
CitySquare, Larry James, aptly
writes. The aim has been to get as many of the TentCity
residents, as possible, directly into housing, and make shelter available to
those who cannot be housed before this week’s final closure date. You can check
out the detailed I-45 Encampment
Closure Plan, and read an exclusive about it by our good friend,
Tasha Tsiaperas, Exclusive:
Dallas plans to close Tent City permanently by May 4.
On Thursday afternoon,
January 28, 2016, our good friend and favorite Dallas Morning News reporter, Tasha Tsiaperas, and I were treated to a
guided tour of The
Cottages at Hickory Crossing. The Cottages are an innovative
permanent supportive housing project of CitySquare. Our tour guide was the man
with the plan himself, Keith Ackerman, the project's Executive
Director.
The amount of thought that
went into each and every aspect of planning, design, and construction of this
project is so impressive. The fifty tiny homes are built in clusters to create
a true sense of community. All of the clusters are centered around a common
courtyard to further build on that.
Each tiny home is identical
on the inside, and will be furnished with the same brand new furnishings and
appliances to maintain a sense of equality. At the same time, residents will be
able to choose some household items, differentiated by color and style. On his
last training visit, Dr. Iain De Jong pointed out this idea as a
Housing First best practice, as it fosters a sense of belonging and connection
to one's domicile.
The skyline view from the
community is one you would pay a pretty penny for, and the number of ongoing
activities planned for residents is one that would rival any luxury rental
community. The community will also be run with an empowering ambiance of
self-governance, and true to the philosophy of Housing First, residents will
enjoy autonomy within their homes.
Of course, Housing First is
not Housing Only. Keith and his staff will be there to support residents moving
in, who might need some time to adjust to living inside. As, this project is intended
for homeless neighbors dealing with multiple challenges, the common
area next to the club house includes a plethora of facilities to support folks
in their journeys. These include a nurse's office, that will be operated by BaylorHospital
(two student nurses joined Tasha and me for the tour), a psychiatric office,
that will be operated by Metrocare Services, and a meeting room for twelve step
program meetings.
Left to right - Tasha Tsiaperas, David Gruber and two Baylor nursing students
As Keith walked us through
the community, and explained all of the different aspects of this intricate
project, I got the sense that with a layperson's eyes I am seeing just the
visible part of the "iceberg." There is a clear sense that in
addition to all of the thoughtful aspects of this project, that I highlighted
above, there is much more below the surface. It is also clear that Keith was
the guy to pull this off. A preacher's kid, who worked in halfway houses, is a
licensed social worker, with years of therapeutic experience, and was chief
operating officer of CitySquare, he has just the type of eclectic skill set to
make this community a reality. He is also one of the friendliest guys you will
ever meet!
For more information,
volunteer opportunities, and to tour the project yourself, check out the
project webpage. Fingers crossed, folks will
start moving in April.
On Thursday night, January
14, 2016, MDHA co-sponsored Faith, Hope and Housing, with and at First
United Methodist Church Dallas. The idea behind this gathering was
to facilitate churches and church members exploring relational ways to empower
our neighbors, who are experiencing homelessness. The evening, organized by
Rebecca Cox, MDHA’s Vice President, attracted a crowd of about eighty
professional and lay church leaders, as well as congregants. The evening began
with warm words of welcome from Dr. Andrew Stoker, Senior Pastor, of First
United Methodist Church Dallas, and a beautiful prayer led by Rev. Jonathan
Grace, of CitySquare.
Rev. Jonathan Grace
Rebecca introduced the idea
of Room
in the Inn, a church winter cold weather shelter program that began
in Nashville
and now exists in more than twenty communities. MDHA hopes to introduce this
program in churches in Dallas.
She then moderated a panel of leaders from Fort Worth, where the program has been up and
running for a few years now. Panel members included, Reverends Dottie Cook,
South Hills Christian Church, Dan Freemyer, Broadway Baptist Church, Page Hines
of First United Methodist Church Fort Worth, and the leader of DRC – Community
Solutions to End Homelessness, Kristy Hroch. They talked about how the program
helped the homeless in Fort Worth,
what a blessing it has been for the churches involved, and how it has inspired
their members. They also took questions from the assembled.
Panel
Rebecca Cox
Our good friend, Keith
Ackerman, Executive Director of CitySquare’s The Cottages
at Hickory Crossing spoke about their needs for household items for
the future residents of that permanent supportive housing project. Those who
wish to help can go to the Target Gift Registry, and using first name:
CitySquare and last name: Cottages, choose items to donate. Rebecca Cox spoke about
how churches can help create “Welcome Home” kits to facilitate smooth move-in
for residents of other housing programs for those experiencing
homelessness.She also distributed this flyer for other
immediate needs churches and church members can help our partners fill. Wayne
Walker, of Our
Calling, spoke about their new app for documenting encampments, and
how people use the app and help them with that effort. Finally, Cindy Crain,
President and CEO of MDHA, spoke about the need for volunteers with the
Homeless Count.
With that, Rebecca adjourned
this very successful communal gathering. We will keep you posted on the Room in
the Inn program, here in Dallas.
If you would like to find out more about how your house of worship can
participate, please contact Rebecca at Rebecca.cox@mdhadallas.org
One of the important new
tools we use in helping these and other folks, who are experiencing
homelessness, is the MDHA Flex Fund. We have written about this on our website,
in the blog post mentioned at the beginning of this post, and elsewhere on this blog. Also, Courtney
Collins interviewed Cindy J. Crain, MDHA President and CEO about this: Losing An Apartment Because You Can’t Pay The $45
Application Fee.
Last week Rebecca shared
another cool story about how the MDHA Flex Fund is paying for a minor but
impactful expense, that is helping a person resolve her housing emergency. If
you have a pet, you know that that little guy or gal is a member of your
family. Imagine you lost pretty much everything, but your little four legged
“son” stuck with you through thick and thin. Well, Judith* does not need to
imagine that. For the last five years she has lived on the street, most
recently in the tent city under I-45. Her little Chihuahua, Simon, has been by her side
(actually, usually cradled in her arms!) the whole time. Due to her hard work
with Rev. Grace, she is now moving into an apartment, where ABC Behavioral Health
will help her with everything she needs to rebuild her life. However, last
week, with everything ready to go, Rev. Grace ran into a final but serious
stumbling block.
The apartment complex, as is
true with many apartment complexes, requires a pet deposit. No big deal, right?
Many of us have been there. Well, for Judith, the $43.75 required for the pet
deposit is a big deal. She does not have that kind of money. As is typical, the
grant under which ABC Behavioral Health will ably serve Judith, cannot be used
to pay for pet deposits. In fact, Rev. Grace could not find any existing
funding source for pet deposits. And yet, this very small but impactful expense
is what stood between Judith (and Simon!) continuing to live under I-45 and
moving into an apartment.Rev. Grace
filled out an MDHA Flex Fund request form, where he documented all of this,
sent it to Rebecca, and she had a check cut to the apartment complex. Judith
and Simon still have a journey ahead of them, but now with the help of the
Outreach Taskforce, ABC Behavioral Health and the MDHA Flex Fund, they are on
the right track to “happily ever after…”
*Judith and Simon’s names
have been changed to protect their privacy. Likewise, photo is of another
really cute Chihuahua!